A practical checklist for reviewing a new supplier
Most supplier problems are visible before the first payment. Not always clearly, and rarely in one place — but visible. This checklist sets out what to record and why it matters.
Start with the company, not the website
A professional website costs very little to produce. A company record is harder to arrange. Begin with the registration details, the trading address, and whether the entity named on the invoice is the entity you have been speaking to.
Record what you find and the date you checked it. Company details change, and a record with a date is more useful later than a recollection without one.
- Registered name and number, and the jurisdiction of registration.
- Trading address, and whether it matches the address used in correspondence.
- Directors or owners, where the register makes them public.
- Whether the bank account name matches the contracting entity.
Read the communication pattern
Pressure is a signal. So is a sudden change of channel, a new contact introduced without explanation, or a reply-to address on a different domain from the sender.
None of these proves anything on its own. Together they describe a pattern that deserves a slower response.
- Free email domains used for a company transaction.
- Domain registered recently, or expiring shortly.
- Reply-to addresses that differ from the visible sender.
- A request to move the conversation to a personal messaging account.
Check the documents against each other
Fraudulent documents are often internally consistent but inconsistent with the rest of the file: a quotation that disagrees with the invoice, a bank letter with a different address, a certificate that predates the company.
Compare names, addresses, account numbers, signatures and dates across every document you have received. Discrepancies are easier to raise before payment than after.
Handle payment changes in writing
A change of bank details is the single most common point of loss in supplier fraud. Treat any such request as a new event that requires independent verification, not a continuation of the existing thread.
Call a number you already hold for the supplier — not one supplied in the message — and confirm the change with a person you have dealt with before. Record who confirmed it and when.
Keep the record
A short file containing the company check, the correspondence, the documents and the payment verification takes an hour to assemble and is valuable if a dispute arises.
If something feels unresolved, the honest options are to pause, to ask for evidence, or to ask someone else to look at it. All three are cheaper than the alternatives.
Reviewed by the Roland Berger Firm commercial risk team. Guidance is general and does not replace jurisdiction-specific advice.
More from Roland Berger Firm Intelligence
Continue reading.
Align before you commitProcurement, Sales and Marketing
How procurement, sales and marketing teams can align demand, supply and positioning without losing sight of risk.
Gather records earlyWhen a shipment goes missing: the first records to gather
A checklist covering timelines, shipping references, correspondence and supporting documents.
Read the article: When a shipment goes missing: the first records to gather